Every town has a neighbor it loves to tease, and ours is San Mateo. We say it with affection. After all, it is the place we all end up going to for dinner, for the mall, or for a train. But if you step back for a moment, San Mateo raises a few questions. Here at San Carlos Florist, we have been asking them over the delivery van’s steering wheel for years.
Why Is the Name on Everything?
There is a San Mateo the city. There is San Mateo County. There is the San Mateo–Hayward Bridge, which carries State Route 92 across the bay. The name is the Spanish version of Saint Matthew, and it has been on maps of this area for a very long time. It shows up in the diaries of the Spanish expedition of 1776. So when someone says “I live in San Mateo,” they may mean the city, the county, or simply that they are somewhere on the Peninsula and want to sound confident about it.
Wait, the County Seat Is Not in San Mateo?
This is our favorite bit of Peninsula trivia. The county named after San Mateo is run from Redwood City. San Mateo came very close to being the county seat. An election in May 1874 named it the winner, and then the state supreme court overturned that election in February 1875. The county seat has stayed in Redwood City ever since. So the city by the name has the population and the name, and the next town over has the courthouse. If you are ever in a trivia game and someone asks which city is the county seat of San Mateo County, you are welcome.
San Mateo does have one consolation prize: with about 105,000 residents at the 2020 census, it is the most populous city in the county. That is a lot of neighbors.
Which San Mateo Do You Mean?
This is the question that matters most when you are sending flowers. A few of the places people mean when they say “San Mateo”:
- Downtown, with its historic buildings, restaurants and the Caltrain station.
- Hillsdale, the shopping center and the Caltrain station across El Camino.
- Bay Meadows, the neighborhood built on the site of the old racetrack, which closed in 2008.
- Central Park, the city’s signature park, with its Japanese tea garden and a rose garden.
- Coyote Point, the county park that sticks out into the bay.
They are all San Mateo, and they are not all next to each other. If you tell a friend to “meet me in San Mateo,” you are describing about as clearly as telling them to meet you in the Bay Area. Add a street name.
The Short Version, From Next Door
San Mateo is bigger than we are, busier than we are, and has more restaurants than we can eat our way through. We like it a lot. We also think that our smaller, calmer town has its own charms, which is a very San Carlos thing to say. Both are true, and you can enjoy both.
If you want the real tour, we wrote a longer neighborhood guide to San Mateo, and a separate one on the San Mateo Japanese Garden.
Sending Flowers to San Mateo
Now for the practical part. We deliver to San Mateo, and the single best thing you can do to help a delivery is to give a full street address, a unit number if there is one, and a phone number for the building. Tell us if you are sending to a downtown office or a home near Hillsdale and we will take it from there. Whichever San Mateo you mean, we will find it.